Commercial Dispute Resolution – The ADR Practice
Guide, by Karl J Mackie and others (Butterworths, 2nd Ed)
This book will find a large market in England where mediation
and other forms of Alternative Dispute Resolution are being
used increasingly by the courts and commercial clients.
The book provides a comprehensive analysis of the place of
mediation, and other less used ADR processes such as the mini-trial,
in the whole spectrum of dispute resolution. There are detailed
sections on the processes themselves, advising clients and
the roles of mediator, lawyer and parties. Of particular interest
will be the new sections on personal injury claims and clinical
(medical) negligence.
The authors do not beat about the bush: “not to acquire
ADR skills and experience will put client relations and practice
development at risk”..”it is not hard to argue
that the failure to alert a client to the existence of ADR
is, at best, falling short of best practice.” More positively,
ability to use and advise on ADR will enhance the reputation
of those lawyers and other professionals who use it and give
them the competitive edge over their competitors.
To what extent these words presently apply in Scotland is
open to debate. However, most disputes are settled by negotiation
at some stage. The question may be: at what stage and at what
cost? The advantages of mediation (which is, in reality, assisted
negotiation) which the authors note are likely to have a impact
in Scotland sooner rather than later:
• speed, privacy and reduced cost,
• creative and forward-looking solutions and
maintenance of business and commercial relationships