news

June 2008

 

Judicial Observations

2008 Training Opportunities

Ø      Flagship Mediation and Conflict Management Skills Course: September/October 2008

Ø      The Next Stage: Mediation and Negotiation Skills: September 2008

Ø      Advanced Negotiation Skills: Negotiating in Difficult Situations: October 2008

Appointment of Jamie Whittle as Associate to Core

Second Civil Mediation Council Conference on the Future of Civil Mediation

European Mediation Conference

European Directive on Mediation

Recent Events

Core Reading

Getting to Yes

Global Negotiation Insight Initiative

The Last Word

 

 

Opening Comment

 

In addition to many local matters, Core’s recent mediations have involved parties and legal representatives from Australia, England and the US in significant commercial disputes with participants who have travelled to Scotland to work with our Scottish mediators. Scotland has much to offer as a location for quality services in this growing field.

 

Judicial Observations

 

“ADR in general and mediation in particular, where it is the appropriate ADR mechanism, must become an integral part of our litigation culture. It must become such a well established part of it that when considering the proper management of litigation it forms as intrinsic and as instinctive a part of our lexicon and of our thought processes, as standard considerations like what, if any expert evidence is required……

 

“This will require education; education on the part of litigants, lawyers and the judiciary. Lawyers and judges will need educating so that mediation becomes part of the culture; so that it becomes second nature to us all. The onus lies on you and me to ensure that litigants appreciate mediation’s many benefits: its informality, its confidentiality, the possibility it holds of enabling the parties to reach a consensual resolution to their dispute and to do so more quickly and at lower cost than might well be possible in the zero-sum game which is litigation.

 

“Over and above education, what can the judiciary do? What we certainly cannot do is sit back and do nothing. Those days are now long gone. Active case management and the overriding objective (to deal with cases justly) very properly put paid to the days of the passive judge.”

 

Sir Anthony Clarke, Master of the Rolls, speaking in an individual capacity

at the Second Civil Mediation Council National Conference on the Future of Civil Mediation, Birmingham 8 May 2008

Click here for full text.

 

“Let me end by nailing my colours firmly to the mast. I number myself with Sir Anthony Colman and Sir Gavin Lightman as an enthusiastic supporter of ADR.

 

“It is madness to incur the considerable expense of litigation – in England usually

disproportionate to the amount at stake – without making a determined attempt to reach an amicable settlement. The idea that there is only one just result of every dispute, which only the court can deliver is, I believe, often illusory. Litigation has a cost, not only for the litigants but for society, because judicial resources are limited and their cost is usually born – at least in part – by the state. Parties should be given strong encouragement to attempt mediation before resorting to litigation. And if they commence litigation, there should be built into the process a stage at which the court can require them to attempt mediation – perhaps with the assistance of a mediator supplied by the court.”

 

Excerpt from a speech by Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers,

Lord Chief Justice, entitled Alternative Dispute Resolution: an English Viewpoint, India, 29 March 2008      

Click here for full text.

 

For the first time in Australia, the Supreme and County courts will be able to send disputes - even large commercial cases - out of the courtroom and into mediation, in a pilot project to be announced by Attorney-General Rob Hulls in Tuesday's state budget.

 “We need to think smart when it comes to attempting to solve disputes, and the courts should be a place of last resort," Mr Hulls told The Sunday Age. He said that the traditional, adversarial court system was winner-takes-all, but research had shown that under mediation disputing parties were more likely to take ownership of the outcome.”

Report from Australia 5 May 2008, The Sunday Age, Melbourne

Click here to read more.

 

 

2008 Training Opportunities

 

Flagship Mediation Skills Course

September/October 2008

 

Dates for Core’s next flagship Mediation Training Course – limited places are already filling fast – a maximum of 8 places left.

 

Ø                  Module 1: Dealing with Differences and Disputes using Mediation

17 – 19 September and 2 – 3 October 2008

 

Ø                  Mediator Assessment Module (Optional)

20 and 21 November 2008

**Discounted Early Bird rate available if both modules booked and paid for by 9 June 2008**

Click here to read more and for information about registration before the expiry of the Early Bird deadline or contact Laura Rutherford on 0131-221-2520 or laura.rutherford@core-solutions.com.

 

“I am now converted to mediation as a fantastic means of enabling people to see solutions where they could not.”

 

“My colleagues both work on very high profile projects which require them to deal with a good deal of conflict and I consider your course to be the best there is in helping anyone to meet these challenges.”

 

 

The Next Stage: Mediation and Negotiation Skills

1 - 2 September 2008 (optional third day: 3 September)

 

·         Who and what?

 

For those who have already undertaken initial mediation training and are looking to refresh and enhance skills and techniques in both mediation and negotiation - and to learn about the latest techniques used in difficult situations by leading mediators.

      led by John Sturrock, Bill Marsh, Pamela Lyall and David Fraser

 

·         Comments from last year’s course:

 

“This was a hugely enjoyable and stimulating experience, delivered in an atmosphere of challenge and support.”

 

“This was up amongst the very best courses I have taken part in over the last 20 years.”

“I am sure your collective professionalism and ease helped each of the participants to achieve something somewhat better than each had thought imaginable.”

“I had a great time on your course. I thoroughly enjoyed the company of my fellow attendees. It was a nice reminder of what a lovely city Edinburgh is.  I feel I have picked up a good deal that will be very useful, I would hazard a guess, forever. As well, I think, my confidence has had a little boost which is a good thing. I feel inspired to move forward with a much fuller heart than I had.”

 

Completion of all three days leads to the Core Certificate in Intermediate Mediation and Negotiation Skills

 

For more information, click here. To download a registration form, click here or here for online registration, or contact Laura Rutherford on 0131-221-2520 or laura.rutherford@core-solutions.com.

 

Advanced Negotiation Skills: Negotiating in Difficult Situations

13 October 2008, Glasgow

 

Presented by John Sturrock and Lawrence Kershen, both senior mediators and Queen’s Counsel, whose professional lives have taken them from the Bar to the broad field of conflict resolution.

 

·                     Barriers to Effective Negotiation

·                     Principled and Positional             Negotiators

·                     The Stages of Negotiation

·                     Separating People from the             Problem

 

·                     Rigour and Respect

·                     Effective Preparation

·                     Dealing with Difficult People

·                     Breaking the Logjam

·                     Tips and Techniques

·                     Interactive examples

 

 

Interested? To register click here or contact Laura Rutherford on 0131-221-2520 or laura.rutherford@core-solutions.com.

 

 

Appointment of Jamie Whittle as Associate to Core

 

We are delighted to announce the appointment of Jamie Whittle as an associate to Core. A trained mediator, solicitor and partner with R&R Urquhart, Inverness, Jamie specialises in environmental and planning issues and recently authored the excellent book, "White River", which uses the experience of a journey on the River Findhorn to provoke thinking on a global level about sustainable living. 

 

Pamela Lyall, Core's Director of Mediation Services commented: "Jamie has a great insight into the role of mediation in environmental sustainability and this provides a real opportunity to help develop this area in Scotland." Jamie Whittle said: "I am thrilled to continue and enhance my links with Core for whose work I have a very high regard."

 

Already, Jamie is working with Core, alongside our other recently appointed associate, Charlie Woods, on a project to raise awareness of the use of mediation in the planning system in Scotland. We are pleased to report that Core submitted a successful tender to the Scottish Government and was awarded this contract in May.

 

Second Civil Mediation Council National Conference on the Future of Civil Mediation, Birmingham, 8 May 2008

 

Pamela Lyall reports:

 

This was an excellent conference, full of fascinating talks about the role and place of mediation in the civil court system.  In particular, there were contributions from Jeremy Tagg, Head of ADR Policy and Projects in the Ministry of Justice, who spoke about low cost mediation services and fast and multi-track approaches, and from His Honour Judge Oliver-Jones from Birmingham who spoke enthusiastically about the active role of the judiciary in promoting mediation.  The judge went so far as to speak of the need to move away from the adversarial approach and the need for education of litigants, lawyers and the judiciary.  The Master of the Rolls, Sir Anthony Clarke, gave what the chairman, Lord Justice Brooke described as a “clarion call” about mediation and its role as a sensible way to go forward in the justice system (see above). He was clear that directing mediation is not contrary to Article 6 of the Human Rights Convention.  He also suggested that the costs of mediation might be costs in the cause in the event of non-resolution.  Lord Slynn, former judge in the European Court of Justice, said that mediation was quite the best way of dealing with a vast number of disputes.

 

There were several other interesting contributions about standards and regulation and from Colin Stutt, of the Legal Services Commission. A leading insurer, David Fisher of AXA, spoke of the common sense which mediation introduced and was supported by a senior solicitor who acts for claimants, Martin Cockx. The work of the Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse in Nigeria, the Karachi Centre for Dispute Resolution and peer mediation in Michigan stirred us to think beyond our own shores.

 

Click here to access the Civil Mediation Council website.

 

European Mediation Conference, Belfast, April 2008

 

The conference, jointly organised by the Scottish Mediation Network, was a considerable success.  Keynote speeches by Jan Egeland, Director, Norwegian Institute of International Affairs, President Ahtisaari, Chairman, Conflict Management Initiative, and others, inspired the 400 delegates.  In a series of talks and workshops, we were educated about the extraordinary developments over the last 20 years in conflict resolution in Northern Ireland and the impact which behind the scenes negotiation and mediation played in bringing about the Good Friday Agreement and subsequent reconciliation.  One of the most interesting aspects of the conference was the breadth of participation from across Europe and the pace at which mediation is developing in many countries, particularly in the Balkans.  Much food for thought for us in Scotland!

 

The First Minister, Alex Salmond, wrote to all delegates and his letter contained the following paragraph:

 

“Ten years ago, on Good Friday 1998, international mediators were acknowledged for their contribution to a milestone in the Peace Process in Ireland and it is appropriate that on the anniversary of that historic occasion the themes of this conference are building relationships and getting results.

 

The Scottish Government is a strong supporter of the increased use of alternative forms of dispute resolution, including mediation and is currently providing funding in a number of areas…raising public awareness of the existence and merits of mediation and looking at the issue of quality assurance.”

 

John Sturrock led a workshop session at the conference on Multi Party Mediation. Gavin Davis, Legal Adviser with Standard Life Employee Services Limited was there and writes this report:

 

“For me one of the highlights of the recent European Mediation Conference was the workshop by Core on Multi Party Mediation.  45 delegates from all over Europe took on the roles of representatives of the various stakeholders in the climate change debate from the hydrocarbon industry; concerned citizens; to global bodies like the United Nations.”

 

Click here to read more.

 

European Directive on Mediation

 

The European Parliament recently adopted a Directive on certain aspects of mediation in civil and commercial matters. The purpose of the Directive is to facilitate access to dispute resolution and to promote the amicable settlement of disputes by encouraging the use of mediation and by ensuring a sound relationship between mediation and judicial proceedings.

 

The Directive addresses a number of important aspects, such as training, quality, judicial encouragement of the use of mediation, the confidentiality of the process, the enforcement of agreements resulting from mediation and the effect of mediation on limitation and prescription periods.

 

The Directive applies to cross-border disputes, although it may well encourage Member States to apply the provisions of the Directive to internal mediation processes.

 

Click here to read the key components of the Directive and here to read more about the Directive.

 

Recent Events

Business in Parliament Conference

 

Click here to read remarks (page 20 of the transcript of the Open Forum) on the greater use of mediation made from the back benches of the Scottish Parliament by John Sturrock during this recent conference attended by over 100 business people, ministers and MSP’s at Holyrood.

 

International Trade Mark Attorneys Advanced Mediation Course, Berlin

 

John Sturrock recently had the privilege of co-leading this course, along with Bill Marsh and two colleagues from the US, attended by over 40 international trademark attorneys and lawyers who sit on the INTA Panel of Mediators.

 

Entrepreneurial Exchange

 

A recent supper event run by the Exchange in Glasgow offered a great opportunity to take the benefits of interest-based negotiation and mediation to this important sector of the Scottish economy.

 

Core Reading

 

The recently-published: “I Have a Dream: A Conversation between President George W Bush and Sheikh Osama Bin Laden” (Noa Zanolli, iUniverse) is worth a read!

 

Getting to Yes

 

Click here to read John Sturrock’s article recently published in the Government and Public Affairs pages of The Scotsman. And here to read his Opinion piece on the Grangemouth dispute.

 

Global Negotiation Insight Initiative

 

Click here to read about the leading edge summer programme which originated in Harvard and which is now taking place at the Omega Institute in New York State, headed up by the inspiring leaders in our field, Erica Ariel Fox and Ken Cloke.

 

The Last Word

 

“It is of course a cliché that you can take a horse to water but whether it drinks is another thing entirely. That it is a cliché does not render it the less true. But what can perhaps be said is that a horse (even a very obstinate horse) is more likely to drink if taken to water. We should be doing more to encourage (and perhaps direct) the horse to go to the trough. The more horses approach the trough the more will drink from it. Litigants being like horses we should give them every assistance to settle their disputes in this way. We do them, and the justice system, a disservice if we do not.”

 

Sir Anthony Clarke, Master of the Rolls, speaking in an individual capacity

at the Second Civil Mediation Council National Conference on 8 May 2008

 

 

Please feel free to forward this newsletter to colleagues who may be interested in it.

 

To access Core’s news page, click here.

 

For more information about Core's activities and to view older editions of Core News, please visit our website at:

 

www.core-solutions.com

 

 

If you wish to have your name removed from our subscription list for Core News, please let us know by emailing a message to Core.